In drawing upon adaptive comanagement scholarship and a case in. Procedures and processes embedded in local management, comanagement, adaptive comanagement or adaptive governance arrangements to account for ecological attributes and changes. Collaboration, learning, and multilevel governance. Nadasday 2007 adaptive co management and ecological. Adaptive management persists because it allows action despite. Although the two arose largely independently of one another, some scholars and resource managers have recently begun advocating a. Facing adversity, building resilience, and finding joy by sheryl sandberg, rising strong by. Fikret berkes, natural resources institute, university of manitoba and canada research chair. Innovation as an outcome of adaptive comanagement gary p. Crop science resilient natural resource systems should.
Six easy pieces on autonomy, dignity, and meaningful work and play. Adaptive comanagement is a governance approach gaining recognition. For example, nadasdy 2007 questions the gospel of resilience, and adaptive comanagement, for. Towards integrating political ecology into resiliencebased. Like the science and practice of ecological restoration, adaptive comanagement is rooted in a particular set of socialecological values. In wisconsin alone, over 75,000 acres of grasslands are under dnr management. A parallel focus on enhancing community participation pervades international development recommendations and policy literature. Adaptive management is an approach to managing socialecological systems that fosters learning about the systems being managed and remains at the forefront of environmental management nearly 40 years after its original conception. Sep 14, 2011 resilience and adaptation in the governance of socialecological systems guest editor. The environmental optimism of elinor ostrom the cgo. Sustainability free fulltext adaptive comanagement for. Adaptive management includes the modification of management decisions when better information is available.
Aug 30, 2008 11 adaptive co management and the gospel of resilience paul nadasdy 12 culturing adaptive co management. Nadasdy, p 2007 adaptive co management and the gospel of resilience. Nadasdy, p 2007 adaptive comanagement and the gospel of resilience. Resilience is a feature of social and ecological systems and governance is clearly an important determinant of resilience. Adaptive comanagement is just starting to be applied for climate change. Sep 18, 2015 procedures and processes embedded in local management, co management, adaptive co management or adaptive governance arrangements to account for ecological attributes and changes. New book on adaptive comanagement resilience science. Adaptive comanagement for climate change adaptation. Charting the new territory of adaptive comanagement. We conclude that they can, evaluate the outcomes, and. We compared two concurrent case studies of grizzly bearhuman conflicts in northern canada to assess whether such crises could effect such transformations in bearhuman systems. One of the outcomes of adaptive comanagement is that all actors will ultimately, and to varying degrees, perceive the system as integrated, complex and adaptive, with interactions and feedbacks between resource users, resources, ecosystems, governance and public infrastructure. Adaptive co management and the gospel of resilience, 02012006012007, d.
Two new environmental management paradigms have emerged in the. The sustainability and the environment series provides a comprehensive, independent, and critical evaluation of environmental and sustainability issues affecting canada and the world today. Collaboration, learning and multilevel governance pp. Adaptive comanagement and the gospel of resilience. Collaboration, learning, and multilevel governance, ed. Collaboration, learning, and multilevel governance, toronto. Theory and practice of adaptive co management, vancouver.
References scientific research articles, journals, books. Finding keys to resilience in asymmetries of power nancy doubleday part 4. As many of the individuals advancing the resilience approach share an interest in adaptive co management, it is unsurprising that the metaphor of the adaptive cycle and panarchy have been used to model the process of adaptive co management. Priming adaptation pathways through adaptive comanagement. It has been postulated that the emergence of adaptive co management can be driven by crises that transform socialecological systems with low resilience. Adaptive management co management evaluation resilience complex adaptive systems sustainable livelihoods 1. Doubledaymoving beyond the critiques of comanagement. Olivier ragueneau melanie raimonet camille maze gerard thouzeau. The crisis which led to turfs in chile originated when the traditional migrations of shellfishdivers along the coast became an organized migration in connection to the loco the gastropod concholepas concholepas or chilean abalone export boom.
Catharines, on canada l2s 3a1 bdepartment of geography and environmental studies, wilfrid laurier university, waterloo, ontario, canada n2l 3c5. Adaptive management of socialecological systems craig r. Independent, selfemployed divers and fishers were informally hired by middlemen andor impresarios and. Methods a resiliencebased framework for evaluating adaptive co management. The institutionalization of comanagement discourse and practice. Adaptive co management and the gospel of resilience. One of the biggest challenges faced today is how to sustainably manage socialecological systems for both ecological conservation and human wellbeing. Linking ecology, economics and society in a complex world ryan plummera. Doubledaymoving beyond the critiques of co management. Water governance debates have increasingly recognized the importance of adaptive governance for short and longterm sustainability, especially with respect to increasing climate unpredictability and growing urbanization. Central to co management is the idea that the responsibilities for allocating and using. Resilience thinking is a framework that emerged over the last 40 years as a management strategy for socialecological systems, and a. On this blog ive frequently mentioned his book seeing like a state, and also enjoyed his the art of not being governed.
A resiliencebased framework for evaluating adaptive co. Transcending the adaptationmitigation climate change. Republished in natural resources and aboriginal people in canada. Building socialecological resilience through adaptive. Adaptive co management is just starting to be applied for climate change adaptation. Two new environmental management paradigms have emerged in the past few decades. Childrens ability to use timelines to recall the order and duration of single and repeated actions, leanne lynn gosse. Jul 16, 2008 fikret berkes, natural resources institute, university of manitoba and canada research chair. Emerging concepts in adaptive management springerlink. Knowledge and the politics of land sara b pritchard, steven. Canadian journal of fisheries and aquatic sciences 59, 1851 7.
The resilience of governance systems is determined largely by the attributes of networks, trust, human capital, leadership, etc. This paper investigates the dynamics of the adaptive comanagement. Building socialecological resilience and sustaining adaptive. Adaptive co management acm is a novel manifestation of adaptive governance tailored to the stewardship of complex socialecological systems, where multistakeholder collaboration is required to match the ecological scale and dynamics of a system armitage et al. Janssen emerging commons within artisanal fisheries. For example, nadasdy 2007 questions the gospel of resilience, and adaptive comanagement, for reinforcing existing inequities by not addressing broader aspects of political economy. Finally, to achieve their aim on the ground, proponents of adaptive management began to look for inspiration in the practices of indigenous peoples, a process that in turn led to the idea of adaptive comanagement, the merging of cooperative management comanagement and adaptive management nadasdy 2007, pp. Finding keys to resilience in asymmetries of power nancy doubleday. Armitage, d, berkes, f, doubleday, n eds adaptive co mangement.
Published here under license by the resilience alliance. In drawing upon adaptive co management scholarship and a case in progress of. Adaptive co management is a governance approach gaining recognition. Adaptive comanagement acm is a novel manifestation of adaptive governance tailored to the stewardship of complex socialecological systems, where multistakeholder collaboration is required to match the ecological scale and dynamics of a system armitage et al. As many of the individuals advancing the resilience approach share an interest in adaptive comanagement, it is unsurprising that the metaphor of the adaptive cycle and panarchy have been used to model the process of adaptive comanagement. Pdf adaptive comanagement and the gospel of resilience. A tool for conservation practitioners biodiversity support program, world wildlife fund, washington, dc, 2001. Should enhanced resilience be an objective of natural. Unfortunately, this book cant be printed from the openbook. Adaptive comanagement and the gospel of resilience, 02012006012007, d. Ubc press adaptive comanagement collaboration, learning. Paradoxical gaps in resilient environmental governance. We conclude that they can, evaluate the outcomes, and identify. Theory and practice of adaptive comanagement, vancouver.
Adaptive co management is not only a timely book but also a useful concept for resource governance in a world marked by rapid socioecological change. Adaptive comanagement for climate change adaptation mdpi. A case study of narwhal comanagement in arctic bay, nunavut, aaron t. Adaptive comanagement is just starting to be applied for climate change adaptation. Adaptive comanagement and grizzly bearhuman conflicts in. This paper explores two approaches to understanding such systems. Towards integrating political ecology into resilience. Bridging knowledge systems to enhance governance of. It will be of interest to researchers, environmental practitioners, policymakers, and students in fields across the political and environmental spectrum. Knowledge and the politics of land sara b pritchard. Armitage, d, berkes, f, doubleday, n eds adaptive comangement. The chilean territorial use rights in fisheries turfs within a broader coastal landscape. Adaptive comanagement and the gospel of resilience 225 10 see nadasdy 2003 for a more complete discussion of the structure of the rrssc, the political context in which it functioned, and how it worked.
Introduction co management has had a profound impact on natural resource management and recent efforts to integrate ecology, economics and society. Adaptive comanagement emerged from our findings that over a period of time comanagement tends to work through cycles. These agencies directly manage significant acreage in agricultural areas, including vulnerable acres that would make gains in soil health, water quality, habitat and ghg sequestration by appropriately integrating adaptive rotational grazing into land management. If you need to print pages from this book, we recommend downloading it as a pdf. Adaptive comanagement is not only a timely book but also a useful concept for resource governance in a world marked by rapid socioecological change. Free essays, homework help, flashcards, research papers, book reports, term papers, history, science, politics. Sustainability free fulltext adaptive comanagement. The rise of adaptive management and comanagement followed the nonlinear turn in ecosystem ecology, and is currently linked with the concept of resilience. Drawing on the fields of socialecological systems, disaster management, and organizational resilience, an adaptability lens is combined with healey et al.
1125 872 1492 177 1095 1233 1111 637 134 90 186 455 908 618 397 969 1071 903 933 1218 99 163 42 72 1396 1386 1083 711 1439 413 77 154 266 1416